Home > Expert Advice > Best Mattresses of 2016


Best Mattresses of 2016

2016 has proven, once again, that the mattress industry has no intention of plateauing and will continue to advance sleep technology with impressive momentum. From the rapid growth of bed-in-a-box mattresses to the continued technological advancements from leading brands, there is no end in sight to the continued growth and fresh thinking of the industry. Unsurprisingly, the big S-brands boasted some impressive offerings in 2016, with value being the primary factor for customers. Tempur-Pedic also has an entry in the top 10 mattresses of 2016 with one of their exciting new models, but once again Simmons, Serta, and Sealy are topping the charts in sales and customer satisfaction. Without further ado, here are the best mattresses of 2016!

  1. Queen Sealy Posturepedic Cooper Mountain III Plush Euro Pillow Top Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 8
    • Good for side sleepers and some back sleepers
    • Sealy Embrace Coil System with individually wrapped coils reduces motion transfer
    • Includes pre-compressed SealyCushion Ultra Soft Foam and SealyCushion Extra Soft Foam
    • SolidEdge HD System
    • Great for couples
    $600.00
    SAVE $67.00
    REG $667.00

    The Sealy Posturepedic Cooper Mountain III Plush Euro Pillow Top Queen Size Mattress boasts affordability and numerous comfort features. Constructed using high-quality components, this model offers one of the best values in the entry-level category, and it is the softest model in the standard Posturepedic category.

    With a very soft Comfort Scale rating of 8, this model offers enveloping comfort. The adjustable base-friendly Sealy Embrace Coil System uses individually wrapped coils that perform independently for precise contouring and reduced motion transfer. High-quality polyfoams rest on top of the coil system, providing excellent pressure relief and body contouring. The SealyCushion Ultra Soft Foam and SealyCushion Extra Soft Foam also help contribute to a long mattress life. Both of these foams undergo a pre-compression process to ensure consistency and durability. The center third of the mattress is reinforced using a layer of SealyCool Gel Memory Foam, which provides additional support to the lower back area. This model also utilizes a foam-encased SolidEdge HD System that reinforces the perimeter of the mattress. Solid Edge Support maximizes the amount of viable sleeping space and is important for couples sharing the bed.

    Whether you are shopping for a spare guest room or your own master bedroom, the Mountain III is a great option for super soft comfort. It comes backed by a 10-year non-prorated warranty so you can be confident in your purchase.

  2. Queen Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Adda II Plush Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 4.5
    • 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil System with independently wrapped coils
    • Includes AirCool Foam, GelTouch Foam, and Energy Foam
    • Foam-encased edge support
    • Great for couples
    $542.00
    Free In Home Delivery

    The Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Adda II Plush Queen Size Mattress is another value-oriented model that scored a 4.5 on our Comfort Scale. This affordable mattress is also great for couples and is the entry-level model in the Beautyrest collection. It has a medium-firm comfort level slightly higher than the previous model. While it does not include all of the features that can be found higher up in the Beautyrest line, it is still a great option with a very capable coil system.

    Mattress support is provided through the 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil System, an individually pocketed coil system that utilizes independently performing coils to deliver conforming comfort with deep down support and excellent motion separation. Crafted using high-carbon steel, this adjustable base friendly coil system is extremely durable. The Adda Plush contains three high-quality foams: Two inches of AirCool Foam is included to provide comfort and promote airflow throughout the mattress. A half inch of GelTouch Foam is incorporated to further enhance airflow and breathability to ensure you sleep cool and comfortable. Lastly, Energy Foam helps absorb motion from the sleep surface for deep, restful sleep. A foam-encased edge support system surrounds the perimeter of the mattress to ensure uniform comfort from edge to edge.

    Although this mattress provides firm underlying support, it also offers plush comfort, making it ideal for most sleeping types. If you are on a budget and want a mattress for couples with a versatile level of comfort, the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Adda II Plush Queen Size Mattress is a great choice. Simmons mattresses are well-built and include a 10-year non-prorated warranty.

  3. Queen Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Kenosha Place II Plush Pillow Top Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 6.5
    • Good for back and side sleepers
    • SurfaceCool Fiber in quilt regulates body temperature
    • GelTouch Foam provides pressure relief
    • 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil System utilizes individually wrapped coils
    • Great for couples
    $574.00
    SAVE $15.00
    REG $589.00

    Another value-oriented mattress to make the list is the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Kenosha Place II Plush Pillow Top Queen Size Mattress. With a Comfort Scale score of 6.5, this model is versatile. It is soft enough for side sleepers yet supportive enough for back sleepers. However, some stomach sleepers may find it to be too plush.

    The quilt features SurfaceCool Fiber that helps dissipate body heat to keep you cool and comfortable throughout the night. Beneath the quilt there is a two-inch layer of GelTouch Foam, a CertiPUR-US certified comfort material that combines high-quality polyurethane foam with gel for enhanced pressure relief and durability. The core of the mattress features the Simmons 800 Series Pocketed Coil System, which uses individually pocketed coils to contour and deliver solid support to your body. This adjustable base-compatible coil system is highly beneficial for couples since it reduces transfer of motion. The coil system is encased within a foam perimeter that keeps comfort and support consistent across the entire sleeping surface.

    Overall, the Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Kenosha Place II Plush Pillow Top Queen Size Mattress is an excellent option for couples who want a versatile, medium-soft mattress. Simmons mattresses are recognized for their high quality, and this model comes complete with a 10-year non-prorated warranty to ensure your lasting satisfaction.

  4. Queen Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Kenosha Place II Plush Mattress

    • Affordable option
    • Versatile Comfort Scale rating of 6
    • Can accommodate side, back, and stomach sleepers
    • 800 Series Beautyrest Pocketed Coil System utilizes individually wrapped coils
    • Includes AirCool Foam, Energy Foam, and GelTouch Foam
    • Foam perimeter keeps comfort consistent from edge to edge
    • Great for couples
    $426.00
    SAVE $96.00
    REG $522.00

    Another value-oriented mattress to make the list is the Simmons Recharge Kenosha Plush Queen. This model boasts dependable support features and a variety of high-quality foams. With a Comfort Scale rating of 6, this model is highly versatile. It is soft enough to contour to your curves, but it is also firm enough to provide good support. There is enough mattress support for back sleepers, enough padding for side sleepers, and the surface is rigid enough for most stomach sleepers. The core of the mattress features the Simmons 800 Series Pocketed Coil System, which uses individually pocketed coils to contour and deliver solid support to your body. This adjustable base compatible coil system is highly beneficial for couples since it reduces transfer of motion. The coil system is encased within a foam perimeter that aids in keeping comfort and support consistent across the entire surface. This model also includes three high-quality foams: AirCool Foam provides comfort and promotes airflow, Energy Foam helps absorb motion, and GelTouch Foam provides more airflow to help you sleep cool. Overall, the Simmons Recharge Kenosha Plush Queen is an affordable mattress that offers a balance of support and plush comfort. Perfect for couples on a budget, this is a great choice for mid-range comfort. Simmons mattresses are recognized for their high quality, and this model comes complete with a 10-year non-prorated warranty to ensure your lasting satisfaction.

  5. Queen Serta Perfect Sleeper Sapphire Suite Double Sided Pillowtop Mattress

    • Top Serta Hotel Suite model
    • Versatile Comfort Scale rating of 5
    • Will accommodate back, side, and stomach sleepers
    • Double-sided, can be flipped
    • Includes Zone Active 5-Zone Foam Topper, PillowSoft Foam, and Serta Insulator Pad
    • Continuous Support System provides solid support, especially to the lower lumbar area of the back
    • Foam-encased edge support
    $849.00
    Free In Home Delivery

    Another Serta mattress to make the list is the Serta Perfect Sleeper Hotel Sapphire Suite Double Sided Pillowtop Queen Mattress. This mattress has a versatile comfort and retains the double-sided construction that many still prefer. This mattress is the top model in Serta’s Hotel Suite collection, and it offers a neutral level of comfort. With a Comfort Scale rating of 5, it has a great blend of softness and support that will satisfy back, side, and stomach sleepers alike.

    Layers of foam include the Zone Active 5-Zone Foam Topper, PillowSoft Foam, and the Serta Insulator Pad. These foams soothe pressure points and work together to provide additional cushioning for a soft initial feel. Support is provided by Serta’s Continuous Support System. This adjustable base compatible system consists of a single, continuous wire that forms hundreds of connected coils that provide sturdy support, especially to the lower lumbar area of the back, though motion transfer reduction is limited. A foam-encased edge support system ensures consistency in comfort across the entire surface, maximizing the viable sleeping area.

    Whether you are shopping for your own master bedroom or a spare guest room, this highly versatile Queen pillow top mattress is an excellent choice. It is double-sided, so you can flip it from time to time to ensure a fresh feel and even wear. This model comes complete with a 10-year non-prorated warranty, so you can purchase it with confidence.

  6. Queen Serta Perfect Sleeper Regal Suite Double Sided Firm Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 3
    • Great for back and stomach sleepers
    • Double-sided, can be flipped
    • Includes SupportFoam and Serta Insulator Pad
    • Continuous Support System provides solid support, especially to the lower lumbar area of the back
    • Foam-encased edge support
    $844.00
    Free In Home Delivery

    The Serta Perfect Sleeper Hotel Regal Suite Double Sided Firm Queen Mattress is another double-sided mattress to make the list. With a medium-firm Comfort Scale rating of 3, this model is ideal for back and stomach sleepers who enjoy comfort that is firm but not hard. This level of comfort is achieved with the addition of advanced foams.

    SupportFoam and the Serta Insulator Pad work together to offer extra cushioning for a softer initial impact. These foams also soothe pressure points, preventing tossing and turning. Support is provided through Serta’s Continuous Support System. This adjustable base-friendly coil system features hundreds of connected coils that work together to provide solid support, especially to the lower lumbar region of the back. You can sleep all the way at the edges thanks to the foam-encased edge support system, which ensures consistency in comfort across the entire surface of the mattress.

    The Serta Perfect Sleeper Hotel Regal Suite Double Sided Firm Queen Mattress is a great choice if you prefer medium-firm comfort. Since it is double-sided, you can flip it occasionally to get a fresh feel and ensure even wear over time. Serta is a name you can trust, and this model includes a 10-year non-prorated warranty to ensure your lasting satisfaction.

  7. Queen Serta Perfect Sleeper Sapphire Suite Double Sided Firm Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 3
    • Designed for back and stomach sleepers
    • Double-sided, can be flipped
    • Includes SupportFoam and Serta Insulator Pad
    • Continuous Support System provides solid support, especially to the lower lumbar area of the back
    • Foam-encased edge support
    $904.00
    Free In Home Delivery

    The Serta Perfect Sleeper Hotel Sapphire Suite Double Sided Firm Queen Mattress is the top model in Serta’s Hotel Suite collection. This double-sided Serta mattress is an affordable option for couples who enjoy a firm comfort level. Scoring a 2.5 on our Comfort Scale, it is suitable for back and stomach sleepers who prefer firm support.

    This model gets its firm feel from multiple layers of durable foams on top of a tried-and-true innerspring system. SupportFoam and the Serta Insulator Pad are incorporated to cushion pressure points that can lead to tossing and turning. Support is provided by Serta’s Continuous Support System, which uses hundreds of connected coils to provide sturdy support, especially to the lower lumbar area of the back. Consistent comfort from edge to edge is achieved with the help of a foam-encased support system, helping you make the most of the Queen size.

    An excellent option for couples who prefer a firm, double-sided mattress with plenty lower back support, this model is well-built and includes a 10-year non-prorated warranty so you can count on enjoying it for a long time.

  8. Queen Sealy Posturepedic Cooper Mountain III Cushion Firm Euro Pillow Top Mattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 4.5
    • Great for back and stomach sleepers
    • Includes SealyCushion Extra Soft Foam and Sealy Cushion Ultra Soft Foam
    • SealyCool Gel Memory Foam reinforces lower back
    • Sealy Embrace Coil System uses individually wrapped coils for precise support and motion reduction
    • SolidEdge HD System
    • Great for couples
    $633.00
    SAVE $70.00
    REG $703.00

    The cost-effective Sealy Posturepedic Cooper Mountain III Cushion Firm Euro Pillow Top Queen Size Mattress is a value-oriented model which scored a 4.5 on our Comfort Scale. Its medium-firm comfort contours well to the lower back while still providing firm underlying support. These features make it suitable for most back sleepers and stomach sleepers.

    This model contains SealyCushion Extra Soft Foam plus SealyCushion Ultra Soft Foam to help it closely contour to the curves of the body. These layers work alongside a reinforced center made using SealyCool Gel Memory Foam to deliver targeted lower back support. All of the comfort materials are pre-compressed to ensure even wear and a long comfort life. Support is provided with the help of the Sealy Embrace Coil System. This adjustable base-friendly system uses individually wrapped coils to provide precise support. This design boasts low motion transfer, making it an excellent choice for light sleepers and couples. Sealy’s SolidEdge HD System surrounds the perimeter of the mattress to ensure uniform comfort and combat roll-off, increasing the viable surface area.

    In all, the Sealy Posturepedic Cooper Mountain III Cushion Firm Euro Pillow Top Queen Size Mattress is an affordable option that is perfect for couples who prefer medium-firm comfort. Dependably made by Sealy, this mattress comes complete with a 10-year non-prorated warranty.

  9. Queen TEMPUR-Flex SupremeMattress

    • Comfort Scale rating of 6.5
    • Dynamic Support Layer ensures contouring and support
    • Includes TEMPUR-ES and TEMPUR-Response foams
    • Quilt uses SmartClimate System to regulate temperature
    • Removable EasyRefresh Top Cover repels allergens and microorganisms
    $2,799.00
    Free Express Delivery

    Though the list is dominated by the three big S-brands, the Tempur-Flex Supreme Queen Mattress also earned a spot among the best mattresses of the year. This Tempur-Pedic mattress utilizes a series of high-grade comfort materials and is available at a lower price point. It has a rating of 6.5 on our Comfort Scale, demonstrating that it offers a blend of softness and support. This medium-soft comfort level will work well for most sleepers since the foams contour well while simultaneously being supportive.

    At the heart of this model is the Dynamic Support Layer, which provides both contouring and deep-down support by using densely arranged precision coils. Working together, TEMPUR-ES and TEMPUR-Response foams provide the level of contouring that the Tempur-Pedic brand is renowned for. These expertly designed comfort materials respond even faster than typical Tempur-Pedic foams, improving upon the already impressive design that made the Tempur-Pedic brand famous. At the surface of the mattress is the SmartClimate System, which gives the quilt a comfortably cool sleeping temperature and helps reduce perspiration. Made using flexible fabric, the EasyRefresh Top Cover utilizes antimicrobial properties to resist microorganisms like dust mites to provide you with a healthier sleeping environment with fewer allergens. This cover can be easily removed for washing.

    To summarize, this mattress is an excellent choice for couples who want the quality of a Tempur-Pedic at a good value. Constructed with care, this mattress is backed by a 10-year non-prorated warranty.

There you have it for the best mattresses of 2016! While there are plenty of other excellent products out there, these 10 stood out for their value, technology, and dependability. If you are in the market for a great mattress at a great price, these options are a great place to start. If you’re interested in learning more about these and countless other mattresses, you've come to the right place. Browse thousands of products and use the Mattress Research Center to learn everything you need to know about buying your next mattress.

Sale Ends May 22nd Extended May 24th