Mattress Research Center > Customer Reviews > Pillowtop Mattress Reviews

Pillow Top Mattress Reviews

Contents: Reviews | Top Rated Mattresses | Collections | Additional Info

Pillow Top Mattress Customer Reviews: 4.6 Stars out of 5

Purchasing a new mattress isn't always easy, especially when you see countless mattresses with the level of comfort you desire. In order to give you a better picture of what you can expect from the various pillow top mattresses we sell, we have assembled an analysis of how our customers have rated and reviewed their pillow top mattresses. These are people who have purchased a pillow top mattress from US-Mattress within the last few years and kindly shared their opinion with us. We're presenting reviews from both the satisfied and dissatisfied customers, so that you can learn as much about your potential mattress as possible.

Our pillow top mattress review data has helped us identify the top pillow top mattresses, along with the most commonly reported pros and cons. This data will help you to make an educated purchase and leave you feeling more confident about the decision you make.

Top Rated Pillow Top Mattresses

Beautyrest Black
from $1,664.00
Reg $3698 | 50% + 10% OFF
from $1,174.00
Reg $3348 | 50% + 10% OFF
from $1,149.00
Reg $2498 | Save 50% + Rollback!
from $1,029.00
Reg $2458 | 50% + 10% OFF
Posturepedic Plus
from $981.00
Reg $3269 | 50% + 40% OFF
from $720.00
Reg $1919 | 50% + 25% OFF
from $720.00
Reg $1919 | 50% + 25% OFF
from $528.00
Reg $1319 | 50% + 20% OFF
from $364.00
Reg $969 | 50% + 25% off

Positive Pillow Top Mattress Reviews: Comfortable, Soft Feel, Good Support, Affordable Price, Great Quality

Our customers shared a lot of positive feedback about their pillow top mattresses. After reading through each review, we found the following to be the most common positive aspects.

Here are some actual reviews from satisfied customers:
  • "If you require a Firm Mattress like me, but also like a little softness, this is the mattress for you. This mattress gives you firm support without feeling you are sleeping on the floor. I spent 2 months researching and reviewing various brands; made trips to Macy's, Sleepy's and a few other not so friendly stores. I realized Simmons is the best mattress bar none, it's worth the extra money."

    - Mark from Washington DC, Simmons Beautyrest TruEnergy Tabitha owner
  • "Comfortable bed, very pleased. Great support without being too soft. Son and family members agree :)"

    - Gregory from Maryland, Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Kenosha Place owner
  • "So Plush and comfortable, I love it! Getting the best sleep ever."

    - Mary from New York, Stearns & Foster Romona owner

Negative Pillow Top Mattress Reviews: Develops Cavity, Too Soft

Out of all of the reviews submitted, there were very few complaints. Those who were dissatisfied with their mattress spoke of two primary issues.

The main issues reported by our customers were:

Our Perspective

Fortunately, most comfort issues are quickly resolved. Here is our perspective on the most common complaints.

Pillow Top Mattress Collections

We carry some of the best pillow top mattresses from some of the world's most recognized brands. Here are the most popular mattress collections with top-rated pillow top mattresses.

Simmons Beautyrest Recharge

Simmons Beautyrest Recharge is the first line in the Beautyrest series, and it features affordable mattresses with Beautyrest's innovative Recharge technology. The Air Cool Design in the Recharge mattress features AirCool Foams and a ventilated edge that enable air to flow through the mattress, allowing for cool, consistent comfort. Recharge mattresses offer support through Beautyrest's proven Pocketed Coil System, which features hundreds of individually wrapped coils that work independently to contour to your body while providing ideal support to your back.
Shop our Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Pillow Top Mattresses

Serta Perfect Sleeper

Serta created their Perfect Sleeper series as a brand devoted to eliminating restless and sleepless nights. In partnership with the National Sleep Foundation (NSA), Serta concluded that the top five issues that cause people to struggle with sleep are the following:tossing and turning, a lack of support that results in back pain, sleeping too hot or too cold, feeling the motion from a partner's movement, and mattress roll-off or sag. Since Serta designed the Perfect Sleeper series to address not just one, but all of the top five sleep disturbances, every type of sleeper can find relief and see an improvement in sleep quality.
Shop our Serta Perfect Sleeper Pillow Top Mattresses

Sealy Posturepedic

The Sealy Posturepedic innerspring was designed in cooperation with leading orthopedic surgeons to provide correct support for your back and body. The new titanium-alloy Apex Coil is individually wrapped to provide exceptional motion separation, while conforming to the shape of each sleeper's body to offer the most customized support. With a Posturepedic mattress, your back gets the support it needs, resulting in better blood circulation and a more restful night's sleep. Sealy spends more than twice as much on research and development than its closest competitor, and more than all other manufacturers combined. Posturepedic mattresses feature the most advanced bedding technology in the industry today.
Shop our Sealy Posturepedic Pillow Top Mattresses

Stearns & Foster

Stearns & Foster's twice tempered, individually wrapped titanium alloy coil systems conform to the curves of each sleeper's body while providing exceptional motion transfer and individual support. This type of coil is the perfect answer for light sleepers who sleep with a partner who moves throughout the night. Also, Stearns & Foster Golden Elegance and Silver Dream mattresses feature the revolutionary Intellicoil Wrapped Titanium Innerspring, which is a dual stage coil within a coil design that provides initial contouring followed by deep down support. The Intellicoil expands upon the properties of their single stage coil and is far more durable, meaning that you can enjoy enhanced motion separation, maximum durability, and a longer comfort life.
Shop our Stearns & Foster Pillow Top Mattresses

Restonic Comfort Care

Restonic Comfort Care mattresses offer consumers better nights of sleep with more support than the competition. Restonic's Marvelous Middle is a system that reinforces the center third of the mattress to provide more support to each sleeper's lower back. These added coils allow each Restonic Comfort Care mattress to provide 25% more support than mattresses that use traditional innerspring systems. This makes Comfort Care mattresses an excellent choice for sleepers who struggle with lower back pain. Select Comfort Care mattresses feature individually wrapped coils, which provide individual support and block the transfer of motion. Wrapped coil systems are an excellent choice for light sleepers who share a bed with a restless partner. When one person moves or gets out of bed during the night, the other sleeper won't feel those movements and will remain in a deep sleep.
Shop our Restonic Comfort Care Pillow Top Mattresses

Spring Air Back Supporter

The Spring Air Back Supporter represents Spring Air's continued commitment to designing and producing bedding systems that offer a superior sleep experience with exceptional support. The Back Supporter collection offers the perfect combination of comfort and support, using premium latex and memory foam to take pressure off of the shoulders and hips for a more comfortable, restful sleep. The Back Supporter provides lasting comfort, and its patented eco-wood base will support the weight of the mattress and sleeper year after year.
Shop our Spring Air Back Supporter Pillow Top Mattresses

Additional Information

  • Stearns & Foster, Serta, and Spring Air scored just slightly higher than our other brands in terms of customer satisfaction.
  • Pillow top mattresses were the most popular in California, New York, and Texas.

Done with your research?

Shop Pillow Top Mattresses

Join the Discussion

After you comment, click Post. If you're not already logged in you will be asked to log in or register.
comments powered by Disqus

Our Most Popular Articles

mattress size info

Mattress Size Information

Compare mattress sizes and decide which is best for you. King, California King, Queen, Full, Twin XL, Twin, Crib, read summaries on them all.
sleeping on side mattress

Best Type of Mattress For a Side Sleeper

If you're a side sleeper, then it's important that you choose the right mattress. Otherwise, you may find yourself tossing and turning through the night and waking with aches and pains.
best pillow top mattress

Best Pillowtop/Euro Top Mattress

Our mattress experts have hand selected the best pillow top and euro top mattresses in our collection.