Top Rated Mattresses
Plush Mattress Customer Reviews: 4.4 Stars out of 5
Purchasing a new mattress isn't always easy, especially when you're trying to find a specific level of comfort. In order to give you a better picture of what you can expect from the various plush mattresses we sell, we have assembled an analysis of how our customers have rated and reviewed their plush mattresses. These are people who have purchased a plush mattress from US-Mattress within the last few years and kindly shared their opinion with us. We're presenting reviews from both the satisfied and dissatisfied customers, so that you can learn as much about your potential mattress as possible.
Our plush mattress review data has helped us identify the top pillow top mattresses, along with the most commonly reported pros and cons. This data will help you to make an educated purchase and leave you feeling more confident about the decision you make.
Top Rated Plush Mattresses
Positive Plush Mattress Reviews: Comfortable, Soft Feel, Good Support, Good Price
Most of our customer reviews mentioned the positive aspects of plush mattresses. After reading each review, we found that there were common aspects that sleepers enjoyed.
- Comfortable: 51% of respondents
- Soft Feel: 32% of respondents
- Good Support: 30% of respondents
- Good Price: 26% of respondents
- Holds Shape: 12% of respondents
- Great Quality: 11% of respondents
- Reduce Back Pain: 11% of respondents
- Sturdy: 8% of respondents
Here are some actual reviews from satisfied customers:
- "This bed is the best I've ever purchased! I look forward to going to sleep at night! It isn't too soft nor firm. I had buyers remorse, but once it was delivered and slept the first night on it, I believe it was the best investment I've ever made."
- Fred from South Carolina, Bassett owner
- "I had been sleeping on a very bad mattress for a long time. Was waking up during the night way too much and feeling tired in the morning. This mattress is sooo comfortable its like your sleeping on a giant pillow. Has a nice medium feel , not too firm or too soft. I now fall asleep faster and sleep through the night, feeling refreshed in the morning. I should have gotten this mattress a long time ago. Delivery was a breeze . Mattress was in place and done in minutes."
- Mark from Pennsylvania, Sealy Hosta owner
- "I feel like I am sleeping on a cloud. My pillow-top mattress. Is so comfortable. I am sleeping better and when I wake I am so refreshed."
- Kay from New York, Sealy Kailua owner
Negative Plush Mattress Reviews: Develops Cavity, Too Soft
The vast majority of our customers were pleased with their plush mattress. In the negative reviews, there were two primary issues that were reported.
The main issues reported by our customers were:
- Develops Cavity: 5% of respondents
- Too Soft: 5% of respondents
Fortunately, most comfort issues are quickly resolved. Here is our perspective on the most common complaints.
- Develops Cavity: All brand new memory foam mattresses conform to your body. Typically, the conformity enhances the sleeping experience. But just like a new pair of shoes, they will feel firm at first, but then mold to your shape after a break-in period. However, if the mattress indentation becomes larger than normal, it could signal a manufacturing defect. In that case, the manufacturer will exchange the mattress with a brand new one.
- Too Soft: To help customers understand how hard or soft a mattress is, we have a 10-point mattress Comfort Scale® . Of course, it's not always 100% accurate, since one person's "hard" is another person's "soft". Luckily, we also provide a 100-Day Comfort Guarantee. If a customer would like to exchange his or her mattress, we'll accept an exchange up to 100 days after delivery. (Find out more about our guarantees and policies).
Plush Mattress Collections
We carry plush mattresses made by some of the world's most recognized brands. Here are the most popular mattress collections with top-rated plush mattresses.
Stearns & Foster
Stearns & Foster's twice tempered, individually wrapped titanium alloy coil systems conform to the curves of each sleeper's body while providing exceptional motion transfer and individual support. This type of coil is the perfect answer for light sleepers who sleep with a partner who moves throughout the night. Also, Stearns & Foster Golden Elegance and Silver Dream mattresses feature the revolutionary Intellicoil Wrapped Titanium Innerspring, which is a dual stage coil within a coil design that provides initial contouring followed by deep down support. The Intellicoil expands upon the properties of their single stage coil and is far more durable, meaning that you can enjoy enhanced motion separation, maximum durability, and a longer comfort life.
Shop our Stearns & Foster Plush Mattresses
Serta Perfect Sleeper
Serta created their Perfect Sleeper series as a brand devoted to eliminating restless and sleepless nights. In partnership with the National Sleep Foundation (NSA), Serta concluded that the top five issues that cause people to struggle with sleep are the following:tossing and turning, a lack of support that results in back pain, sleeping too hot or too cold, feeling the motion from a partner's movement, and mattress roll-off or sag. Since Serta designed the Perfect Sleeper series to address not just one, but all of the top five sleep disturbances, every type of sleeper can find relief and see an improvement in sleep quality.
Shop our Serta Perfect Sleeper Plush Mattresses
Simmons Beautyrest Recharge
Simmons Beautyrest Recharge is the first line in the Beautyrest series, and it features affordable mattresses with Beautyrest's innovative Recharge technology. The Air Cool Design in the Recharge mattress features AirCool Foams and a ventilated edge that enable air to flow through the mattress, allowing for cool, consistent comfort. Recharge mattresses offer support through Beautyrest's proven Pocketed Coil System, which features hundreds of individually wrapped coils that work independently to contour to your body while providing ideal support to your back.
Shop our Simmons Beautyrest Recharge Plush Mattresses
The Sealy Posturepedic innerspring was designed in cooperation with leading orthopedic surgeons to provide correct support for your back and body. The new titanium-alloy Apex Coil is individually wrapped to provide exceptional motion separation, while conforming to the shape of each sleeper's body to offer the most customized support. With a Posturepedic mattress, your back gets the support it needs, resulting in better blood circulation and a more restful night's sleep. Sealy spends more than twice as much on research and development than its closest competitor, and more than all other manufacturers combined. Posturepedic mattresses feature the most advanced bedding technology in the industry today.
Shop our Sealy Posturepedic Plush Mattresses
- Stearns & Foster and Serta scored just slightly higher than our other brands in terms of customer satisfaction.
- Plush mattresses were the most popular in California, New York, and Texas.