Best Customizable Mattress

Are you looking for a mattress you can personalize for your sleep needs? If so, you’re not alone. Many mattress companies have responded by making fully customizable mattresses, allowing shoppers to ensure they’re getting just the comfort level they need.

But which customizable mattress is the best value? Which one is uniquely suited to your specific sleep needs? Read on for a few recommendations.

By clicking on the product links in this article, US-Mattress and Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read the full disclosure statement.

Best Customizable Mattress - Top Picks

Helix - Editor’s Choice

Helix Midnight mattress

There’s a reason why Helix wins our Editor’s Choice distinction. The Helix line has really set the bar for mattress customization. When you visit their website, you can take the Color-MATCH sleep quiz, telling them all about your preferred sleeping position and comfort needs. You’ll then be matched to one of a number of Helix mattresses, designed to give you just the support you need.

Learn more in our Helix Mattress Review.

Pros Cons
  • Great for couples
  • High level of customization
  • High-quality, durable materials
  • Some off-gassing
  • Some noise

Save up to $200 + 2 FREE Dream pillows


Check Price


Brooklyn Signature - Best Hybrid Mattress

Brooklyn Signature mattress in a room

The Brooklyn Signature offers you carefully designed layers of foam and innerspring coils, providing you with just the right balance of support and responsiveness. We’ll also give the Brooklyn Signature bonus points for being one of the best cooling mattresses. You’ll have three firmness levels to choose from: Soft, medium, and firm.

Read more in our Brooklyn Bedding Signature Review.

Pros Cons
  • Sleeps cool
  • Three firmness levels to choose from
  • Excellent pressure relief
  • Some off-gassing
  • Can take some time (30 days) to break in

Get 25% off


Check Price


Saatva Solaire - Best Adjustable Mattress

Saatva Solaire mattress on an adjustable base

The Saatva Solaire is an adjustable airbed; it comes with a remote control that lets you pick from one of 50 different comfort levels, tweaking your sleep experience to be just right. We’ll also point out its exemplary lumbar support. Note that you can pick different comfort levels on each side of the bed, which makes this a great choice for couples.

Read more in our Saatva Solaire Mattress Review.

Pros Cons
  • Excellent lumbar support
  • Excellent for couples
  • High-quality, durable materials
  • 50 firmness levels to choose from
  • Some off-gassing
  • $99 return fee
  • Not recommended for budget shoppers

$200 off any purchase of $1000 or more


Check Price


Layla - Best for Back and Joint Pain

Couple hugging and smiling on a Layla mattress

The Layla memory foam mattress has a unique, flippable design; you can easily swap between the firm side and the soft side of the mattress. The firmer side, in particular, comes with a high level of pressure point relief, which makes it easy for us to recommend it to anyone with back or joint pain.

Read more in our Layla Mattress Review.

Pros Cons
  • Relieves pressure
  • Two firmness options
  • Memory foam infused with copper, which helps with inflammation
  • May take two or three weeks to break it in

$150 off + 2 Free Pillows + Microfiber sheets + Mattress Protector


Check Price


Zenhaven - Best Natural Latex Mattress

Zenhaven mattress

Made with Talalay latex, the Zenhaven bed scores high marks in motion transfer and responsiveness. On top of that, it has two firmness options to choose from. Start on luxury plush, or flip to the gentle-firm side. Thanks to its latex core, it’s also one of the best latex mattresses.

Learn more in our Zenhaven Mattress Review.

Pros Cons
  • Made with natural materials
  • Excellent for motion isolation and responsiveness
  • Great choice for seniors
  • Some off-gassing
  • May take 30 days to break in
  • Not recommended for budget shoppers

$200 off any purchase of $1000 or more


Check Price


Nolah - Best for Combination Sleepers

Brooklyn Signature mattress in a room

Combination sleepers are those who tend to toss, turn, or change positions during the night. If that’s you, consider the Nolah Signature mattress. Our testing also finds that it works well for back sleepers and for stomach sleepers. It comes with a flippable design and two firmness options.

Find out more in our Nolah Signature Mattress Review.

Pros Cons
  • Two firmness levels to choose from
  • Works well for back, stomach, and combination sleepers
  • Not recommended for budget shoppers
  • Lackluster edge support

Up to $250 Off 10" Original + 2 Free Pillows


Check Price


Compare the Best Mattresses

As you shop for a new mattress, it can be helpful to compare materials, warranties, and other key specs.

Mattress Name Quick Overview Special Offer

Helix

Helix logo

Material: Hybrid

Customer Rating: 4.6/5

MA Score: 8.9/10

Delivery: 3-7 business days

Trial Period: 100 nights

Warranty: 10 years

Price: $$

Save up to $200 + 2 FREE Dream pillows

Check Price

Brooklyn Signature

Brooklyn Bedding logo

Material: Hybrid

Customer Rating: 4.7/5

MA Score: 9.1/10

Delivery: 4-8 business days

Trial Period: 120 nights

Warranty: 10 years

Price: $$

Get 25% off

Check Price

Saatva Solaire

Saatva logo

Material: Airbed

Customer Rating: 4.9/5

MA Score: 8.7/10

Delivery: Free white-glove delivery

Trial Period: 180 nights

Warranty: 25 years

Price: $$$$$

$200 off any purchase of $1000 or more

Check Price

Layla

Layla logo

Material: Copper-infused memory foam

Customer Rating: 4.5/5

MA Score: 8.8/10

Delivery: 4-7 business days

Trial Period: 120 nights

Warranty: Lifetime warranty

Price: $

$150 off + 2 Free Pillows + Microfiber sheets + Mattress Protector

Check Price

Zenhaven

Zenhaven logo

Material: Airbed

Customer Rating: 4.9/5

MA Score: 8.7/10

Delivery: Free white-glove delivery

Trial Period: 180 nights

Warranty: 15 years

Price: $$$$$

$200 off any purchase of $1000 or more

Check Price

NolahNolah logo

Material: AirFoam

Customer Rating: 4.8/5

MA Score: 8.6/10

Delivery: Free delivery

Trial Period: 120 nights

Warranty: Lifetime

Price: $$$

Up to $250 Off 10" Original + 2 Free Pillows

Check Price

MA Score: The Mattress Advisor Score is a weighted score that takes into account 14 different factors related to the mattress’ performance, function, convenience, and the brand’s social responsibility.

Compare Features and Materials

Before you purchase a custom mattress, it’s helpful to know exactly what it’s made of. Here’s a glimpse into each of our six featured mattresses.

Helix Brooklyn Signature
Inside layers of Helix mattress Inside layers of Brooklyn Signature mattress

What’s inside:

  • Soft-touch cover: Promotes air flow and helps regulate your body temperature
  • Memory foam comfort layer: Cradles your joints and supports pressure points
  • Polyfoam transition layer: An added layer of cushioning
  • Body shape layer: A pocket coil system adjusts to the shape of your body
  • Dense foam base layer: Provides the mattress with extra support and stability

What’s inside:

  • Gel memory foam topper: Resists body impressions and mediates body heat
  • Comfort layer: Adjusts to the movements of your body throughout the night
  • Support layer: An additional layer of comfort and support
  • Ascension encased coils: More than 1,000 individually wrapped coils to support your body
  • Base support foam: Keeps the mattress sturdy and strong

Scored best in:

  • Motion transfer
  • Edge support
  • Cooling

Scored best in:

  • Pressure relief
  • Edge support
  • Spine alignment
Saatva Solaire Layla
Inside layers of Saatva mattress Inside layers of Layla mattress

What’s inside:

  • Organic cotton pillow top: The top layer of the mattress is soft and cool to the touch
  • Talalay latex layer: Offers zoned pressure relief
  • Gel-infused memory foam: Foam layer keeps you cool and helps support healthy spine alignment
  • Moisture barrier: Guards the inner layers of the mattress from bacteria formation
  • Vulcanized air chambers: Full, customizable body support
  • Power edge enclosure: Helps the mattress run quietly and effectively

What’s inside:

  • Soft side: Copper-infused memory foam keeps you cool and comfy
  • Convoluted air flow layer: Provides air flow and heat dissipation
  • Base support foam: A dense layer of foam helps keep the mattress sturdy and stable
  • Firm side: A second layer of copper-infused memory foam offers a firmer feel

Scored best in:

  • Motion transfer
  • Durability
  • Cooling

Scored best in:

  • Responsiveness
  • Edge support
  • Pressure relief
Zenhaven Nolah Signature
Inside layers of Zenhaven mattress Inside layers of Nolah Signature mattress

What’s inside:

  • Top and bottom layers: There’s a firm side and a plush side, both made to provide zoned support, comfort, and pressure relief
  • Latex support layer: The core of the mattress provides strong, resilient latex

What’s inside:

  • Soft side: The Nolah mattress is made with a cooler foam alternative to memory foam
  • High-resilience foam layer: Offers support and comfort for back and stomach sleepers
  • High-density core layer: Prevents sinking and sagging
  • Firm side: The flip side of the mattress offers a firmer sleep experience, especially good for stomach sleepers

Scored best in:

  • Motion transfer
  • Edge support
  • Responsiveness

Scored best in:

  • Responsiveness
  • Pressure relief
  • Cooling

What is a Customizable Mattress?

Customizable mattresses give you plenty of options for making the bed truly your own. Mattresses in this category allow you a range of firmness options, letting you pick a comfort level that suits your preferred sleeping position. Some customizable mattresses require you to choose a firmness level at the point of purchase. Others can be flipped or tweaked once you have the mattress in your home.

Related: Looking for a firm mattress? Read our best firm mattress review.

Shopping Considerations

Looking for a quality mattress that you can modify and customize? Here are a few shopping considerations.

Type of Mattress

Memory foam: Memory foam mattresses tend to be inexpensive, supportive, and responsive. If there’s a downside, it’s that memory foam often runs hotter than other mattress types. It can be alleviated with cooling gel or with a more porous design.

Innerspring: Individual coils provide support and help the mattress adjust to your movements. Most “traditional” beds are innerspring, though newer innerspring mattresses shouldn’t be nearly as noisy.

Latex: Latex sleeps cool and lasts a long time, though it may also come at a higher price point.

Hybrid: A hybrid mattress combines two or more of the other materials, theoretically offering the best of all worlds.

Performance Factors

Set-up: How long will it take you to have your mattress unboxed and set up on the bed frame or the foundation?

Pressure relief: A good mattress will help evenly distribute your body weight and keep the pressure off sensitive joints.

Spine alignment: Natural spine alignment keeps you from waking up feeling creaky and stiff.

Durability: Look for a mattress that’s truly built to last. A lengthy warranty (10-year warranty at the least) is usually a good sign that the product is durable.

Motion transfer: For couples, it’s important to find a mattress that will muffle each partner’s movements in the night.

Temperature regulation: Look for a breathable mattress that circulates the air.

Responsiveness: Responsive mattresses do a better job adjusting to your movements and your body type.

Edge support: Good edge support prevents your mattress from sagging at the corners.

Price

The price of a good customizable mattress depends on the mattress size, material, and more.

FAQ About Customizable Mattresses

  1. What are the best mattress options for hot sleepers?

    Look for a mattress that’s made with an air-circulating cover; gel-infused foam, or a cool material like latex.

  2. How do sleep trials work?

    You’ll have a certain number of days to break in your new mattress and make sure it’s right for you. Within that window, you can return the mattress for a refund. (Some mattress companies will charge a small return fee.)

  3. How can I be sure my mattress is made without toxic materials?

    Look for a mattress labeled as CertiPUR-US approved.

Summary of Our Top Picks for the Best Customizable Mattress

About the Author Josh Hurst

Josh Hurst lives and writes in Knoxville, TN. A recovering insomniac, he has a long-standing appreciation for the power of a good night's sleep.