Best Mattress Topper

Are you looking to change-up your sleep experience? Rather than spring for a whole new mattress, consider the merits of a new mattress topper. A mattress topper can bring additional comfort and support. It may help you to enhance and customize an already-great mattress. Or, it can help you rehabilitate a mattress that’s taken on some wear and tear.

The question is, which mattress topper is best for your needs? There are several to choose from, and in this article, we’ll run through a few of our favorites.

By clicking on the product links in this article, US-Mattress and Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read the full disclosure statement.

Best Mattress Topper - Top Picks

Helix Plush Mattress Topper - Best Quality Topper

Helix plush mattress topper

Looking for a mattress topper that will transform your already-great mattress into a five-star, hotel-quality sleep experience? The Helix Plush Mattress Topper is a product we recommend. Its generous fiberfill creates a truly plush feel, and it’s also made with bamboo and fiber that keep it tantalizingly soft to the touch.

Learn more about this brand in our Helix mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • High-quality materials
  • Soft to the touch
  • Highly breathable
  • Hypoallergenic
  • There may be a bit of off-gassing when you first open the box

Save up to $200 + 2 free Dream pillows


Check Price



Saatva - Best Customizable Topper

Saatva mattress topper

Saatva’s mattress toppers are made to be sustainable, supportive, and responsive. But what we really like is that Saatva gives you a number of options. Choose between extra-cooling graphite, all-natural latex, or contouring foam. Saatva makes it easy to find the perfect topper to meet your needs.

Learn more about this brand in our Saatva mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Three options to choose from
  • High-quality materials
  • Not the most budget-friendly mattress topper
  • The return window is shorter than most

Get 15% off orders of $2,750+


Check Price


Casper Mattress Topper - Best Cooling Topper

Casper mattress topper

Casper’s mattress topper gives you three layers of foam, providing significant comfort and support to your mattress. Best of all, the foam is designed to promote air flow and mediate your body heat, ensuring a cool sleep experience all night long.

Learn more about this brand in our Casper mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Foam layers offer maximum comfort and support
  • Sleeps cool
  • Not for budget shoppers

Get up to 20% off


Check Price


Puffy Topper - Best Adjustable Topper

Puffy mattress topper

There are a million reasons to love the Puffy mattress topper, ranging from its air-circulating design to its generous 101-night sleep trial. But the reason it makes our list is that Puffy makes it extremely easy to add or remove fill as needed, allowing you to adjust for a firmness level that’s right for you.

Learn more about this brand in our Puffy mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Sleeps cool
  • Adjustable firmness
  • Generous sleep trial
  • Lifetime warranty
  • High-quality materials
  • May be some off-gassing when you open it

Get $300 off + Up to $455 of free accessories


Check Price


Leesa Mattress Topper – Most Versatile Topper

Leesa mattress topper

The Leesa is a well-rounded memory foam mattress topper that we think any sleeper would like…which is why we’re calling it “most versatile.” Highlights of this topper: Exclusive foam combo that’s made for comfort and support; breathable fabric that promotes cooling air flow; a cover that’s easy to unzip and throw into the washing machine as needed.

Learn more about this brand in our Leesa mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Supple, supportive, comforting foam
  • Machine washable
  • Breathable
  • Not as adjustable or customizable as some of the other options

Get up to $500 off mattresses


Check Price


Tuft & Needle Mattress Topper - Best Value Topper

Tuft and Needle mattress topper

Tuft & Needle is known for high standards of quality, and their topper is no exception. It’s made with two inches of premium foam, and backed with a 100-night sleep trial, three-year warranty, and free refunds. All that to say, we think it offers a lot of peace of mind to the buyer and maximizes your bang for buck.

Learn more about this brand in our Tuft & Needle mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Excellent warranty and sleep trial
  • High-quality foam
  • Very responsive
  • Not as adjustable or customizable as some of the other options

Save up to 15% off


Check Price


Avocado Green Topper - Best Premium Topper

Avocado Green mattress topper

Avocado’s products tend to come at a higher price range, so budget shoppers will likely want to look elsewhere. If you’re okay to spend a bit more for a premium-level mattress topper, though, Avocado is worth it. It’s made with exemplary organic and natural materials, contours to the curves of your body, and provides a truly luxurious sleep experience. This is a high-end Talalay latex mattress topper that has much to recommend it.

Learn more about this brand in our Avocado mattress review.

PROS CONS
  • Made with natural and organic materials
  • Contours to the shape of your body
  • High-quality and durable
  • Falls on the higher end of the price spectrum

Save up to $250 on mattresses


Check Price


Compare the Best Mattress Toppers

When shopping for a new mattress protector or top layer, it’s important to consider a few basic specs and features. Here are side-by-side comparisons of our five featured products.

Mattress Name Quick Overview Special Offer

Helix

Helix logo

Material: Polyester, cotton, bamboo

Firmness: Plush

Sleep Trial: 100 nights

Warranty: 1 year

Price: $

Save up to $200 + 2 free Dream pillows

Check Price

Saatva

Saatva logo

Material: Choice between graphite, latex, and memory foam

Firmness: Variable

Sleep Trial: 45 days

Warranty: N/A

Price: $$

Get 15% off orders of $2,750+

Check Price

Casper

Casper logo

Material: Latex foam

Firmness: Plush

Sleep Trial: 100 nights

Warranty: N/A

Price: $$

Get up to 20% off

Check Price

Puffy

Puffy logo

Material: Polyester and bamboo

Firmness: Adjustable

Sleep Trial: 101 nights

Warranty: Lifetime

Price: $$

Get $300 off + Up to $455 of free accessories

Check Price

Leesa

Leesa logo

Material: Foam

Firmness: Medium-plush

Sleep Trial: N/A

Warranty: N/A

Price: $$$

Get up to $500 off mattresses

Check Price

Tuft & Needle

Tuft and Needle logo

Material: Sustainably-sourced latex, cotton, and wool

Firmness: Choose between plush or firm

Sleep Trial: 1 year

Warranty: 10 years

Price: $$$$

Save up to 15% off

Check Price

Avocado

Avocado logo

Material: Sustainably-sourced latex, cotton, and wool

Firmness: Choose between plush or firm

Sleep Trial: 1 year

Warranty: 10 years

Price: $$$$

Save up to $250 on mattresses

Check Price

MA Score: The Mattress Advisor Score is a weighted score that takes into account 14 different factors related to the mattress’ performance, function, convenience, and the brand’s social responsibility.

What is a Mattress Topper?

For those who have never bought a mattress topper before, it can be hard knowing exactly what to look for. One important note is that a mattress topper is not the same thing as a mattress cover. A topper adds a few inches of material, helping you achieve additional comfort and support. A good topper can make a firm mattress feel like a soft mattress. A cover, on the other hand, is mostly intended to protect your mattresses from spills or stains.

A mattress topper can help your bed feel more cozy and supported, especially if your mattress is older and has seen some wear and tear. Mattress toppers can also provide motion isolation, making your movements less disruptive to your sleep partner. Finally, the addition of a mattress topper can help you achieve a cooler sleep experience, preventing overheating during the night. These are just some of the reasons to look for a quality mattress topper.

Shopping Considerations

Not all mattress toppers are created equal, and it’s important to look for one that addresses your needs, your sleeping position, and your budget.

Type of Mattress Topper

Memory foam: Memory foam toppers tend to be a little more plush, and to mold to the shape of your body. They are great for pressure relief, and are often the best bet for those with back pain. Be careful to get one that also promotes air circulation, as some memory foam toppers tend to run hot. The best memory foam mattress topper will be designed with airflow in mind, helping you mediate your body temperature. (Cooling gel, when added to high-density foam, can help with this.)

Learn more about memory foam in our best memory foam mattress guide.

Latex: Latex mattresses tend to run cool, and are often the best option for those who want something eco-friendly. (See also wool mattress topper options.) Note that latex tends to be firmer, and usually isn’t recommended for those who want a plush sleep experience. Also, a latex topper will usually be on the higher end of the price spectrum. But for those who want something sustainably sourced, a natural latex mattress topper is often the best option.

Learn more about latex in our best latex mattress guide.

Fiber: Fiber isn’t quite as durable as other materials, but it’s generally the most budget-friendly option. It tends to be hypoallergenic, as well, and can keep dust mites at bay.

Performance Factors

Pressure relief: When you add a new layer to the top of your mattress, it’s important to think about how it will help distribute weight and keep you from aches and pains. This is an important consideration as you look for the best mattress for back pain. Relief for key pressure points helps keep you from waking up stiff or achy.

Spine alignment: You’ll sleep better if you have a mattress topper that promotes healthy posture throughout the night.

Durability: Make sure you consider the durability of the materials used. Some mattress toppers are more effective than others at withstanding the tests of time.

Motion transfer: Mattress topper reviews often highlight motion transfer, which refers to the way a topper helps minimize disruption when one partner tosses or turns in bed.

Temperature regulation: Look for a quilted mattress topper that promotes air flow and keeps your body cool throughout the night. For hot sleepers, this is a must.

Responsiveness: Some mattress products are better than others for adapting to your movements and helping you change positions. (This is important for combo sleepers, stomach sleepers, etc.) Responsiveness is an indication of how cushioning the mattress topper will feel.

Breathability: You’ll probably want to look for a topper that promotes air circulation, keeping you cool throughout the night.

Price

Naturally, price is a big factor to consider as you look for a new mattress topper. Price will be heavily influenced by the size of your mattress, as well as by the material you choose.

FAQ About Mattress Toppers

  1. How can I tell when a mattress product is eco-friendly?

    It’s always helpful to look into latex or wool mattress toppers. Additionally, check for signs that your product is CertiPUR-US certified.

  2. Do I need a mattress cover and a mattress topper?

    It just depends on your goals. Again, the former helps protect your bedding from stains and spills, while the latter is more about enhancing comfort.

  3. How can I take care of my mattress topper?

    It depends on the type and material. Some are machine washable, and will be labeled as such. Others require spot cleaning.

Summary of Our Top Picks for the Best Mattress Topper

About the Author Josh Hurst

Josh Hurst lives and writes in Knoxville, TN. A recovering insomniac, he has a long-standing appreciation for the power of a good night's sleep.