Casper vs Saatva Mattress Review

Today’s online mattress companies offer unparalleled levels of comfort, support, and convenience. While the Saatva mattress boasts customizable firmness and free white glove delivery, the Casper is a showstopper amongst memory foam beds with its innovative zoned support. Find out which is best for you in this Casper vs Saatva mattress review.

By clicking on the product links in this article, US-Mattress and Mattress Advisor may receive a commission fee at no cost to you, the reader. Read the full disclosure statement.

Casper vs Saatva Side-by-Side Comparison

Casper Mattress Review

Woman sitting on a Casper mattress

  • Type: Memory foam
  • Firmness: Medium-firm
  • Trial Period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10-year warranty
  • Price: $$
  • MA Score: 9.1/10
  • Customer Rating: 4.5/5

Read more in our Casper mattress review.

30% Off Bundles and 10% off Sitewide with code HOLIDAYFLASH


Check Price


Saatva Mattress Review

Saatva mattress near an ocean view

  • Type: Hybrid
  • Firmness: Choose between plush, luxury firm, and firm
  • Trial Period: 180 nights
  • Warranty: 15 years
  • Price: $$$
  • MA Score: 8.7/10
  • Customer Rating: 4.8/5

Learn more in our Saatva mattress review.

Get $200 off


Check Price


Highlights of Casper vs Saatva

What are the primary benefits of the Casper memory foam mattress versus the Saatva hybrid mattress? Here’s a quick highlight reel.

The Casper Mattress

Casper Original Mattress

  • Highly responsive: In our testing, the Casper got a perfect score in responsiveness, which measures the mattress’ ability to adapt and respond to your movements. This makes it an ideal mattress for combination sleepers (people who toss, turn, or change positions in the night).
  • Air circulation: One of the drawbacks of memory foam is that it tends to retain body heat. Casper’s mattress is designed to promote air circulation and mediate body temperature, meaning you’re less likely to wake up feeling sticky and sweaty.
  • Zoned relief: The Casper mattress is designed with zoned support, cushioning your joints and minimizing pain on your sensitive pressure points.

Learn more in our Casper mattress review.

30% Off Bundles and 10% off Sitewide with code HOLIDAYFLASH


Check Price


The Saatva Mattress

Saatva Classic Mattress

  • Built to last: The Saatva is made with highly durable materials, including strong innerspring coils that allow it to support plenty of weight over a long period of time. This mattress is made for the long haul; in fact, we give it a perfect score in the durability
  • Three firmness levels: Get the support you need to match your sleep position. Saatva gives you the option between plush, luxury firm, and firm settings.
  • Free white glove delivery and setup: Not only will Saatva send your new mattress directly to your door, they’ll actually bring it inside, unbox it, and make sure it’s ready for use.

Learn more in our Saatva mattress review.

Get $200 off


Check Price


Features and Materials

How do these two mattress brands compare in terms of features and materials? Let’s take a closer look.

Casper

Inside layers of the Casper mattress

Saatva

Inside layers of the Saatva mattress

What’s inside:

  • Open cell foam: The top layer of memory foam is designed to circulate air and keep you cool
  • Zoned support layer: Memory foam with three ergonomic zones, ensuring pressure relief and spinal alignment
  • Durable support foam: The base layer keeps your mattress steady and stable, and prevents sinkage

What’s inside:

  • Quilted euro pillow top: The top layer of the mattress is luxuriously soft, cozy, and breathable
  • Individually wrapped coils: Innerspring coils support the body and respond to your movements
  • Dual perimeter edge support: Foam encasement adds an extra supportive feel
  • Memory foam layer: Support your back and relieves pressure points
  • Durable steel coils: The bottom layer is strong, breathable, and durable

Scored best in:

  • Responsiveness
  • Spine alignment
  • Edge support

Scored best in:

  • Durability
  • Spine alignment
  • Edge support

Size and Specs

Casper

Saatva

10"

Twin: 39” x 75”

Twin XL: 39” x 80” 

Full: 54” x 75”   

Queen: 60” x 80”

King: 76” x 80”

Cal King: 72” x 84”

11"

Twin: 38” x 75”

Twin XL: 38” x 80” 

Full: 54” x 75”   

Queen: 60” x 80”

King: 76” x 80”

Cal King: 72” x 84”

Durability

Any time you spend money on a new mattress purchase, you want something that’s made for the long haul. The Saatva is made from legendarily high-quality materials, meaning it can hold up any body type for a good long while. We give it a perfect score in durability. The Casper doesn’t wow us quite as much, but we give it an 8 out of 10 in durability, which is nothing to scoff at.

Firmness

How firm do you like your mattress? The Casper offers medium-firmness, which means it works well for back sleepers, stomach sleepers, and side sleepers alike. Its high responsiveness score also makes it perfect for combination sleepers. With Saatva, you’ll get to pick between three firmness settings.

Find more options in our guide to the best firm mattress for you.

Motion Transfer

For couples, it’s important to find a mattress that minimizes nighttime disruptions; for instance, if you have to get up to use the bathroom, you don’t want to jostle your partner awake. Both of these mattresses get decent scores in this category, an 8 out of 10 for Casper and 7.5 for Saatva.

Learn more about the importance of motion transfer in our guide to the best mattress for couples.

Pressure Relief

If you’re looking for even weight distribution and relief from back pain, you may want to consider the Casper. We give it an 8.5 out of 10 in pressure relief, while the Saatva gets a 6.5.

Learn more about the best mattresses for back pain.

Delivery and Returns

Both the Saatva and Casper will ship to your home for free, though only Saatva rolls out the red carpet with free white glove setup. Both companies will allow you to return your mattresses for a full refund, but only if you do so during the sleep trial period (100 nights for the Casper, 180 for Saatva). Note that Saatva charges a $99 return fee.

FAQ about the Casper Mattress

  1. Should I flip my Casper mattress?

    No. This foam mattress comes with a defined top and bottom and is made to be used that way. You can rotate it once or twice a year if you like.

  2. Is the Casper made from eco-friendly materials?

    The foam materials used in the Casper are CertiPUR-US certified, which means they uphold rigorous standards of emissions testing.

FAQ about the Saatva Mattress

  1. How much body weight does Saatva support?

    The Saatva coil system is built to support 300 pounds per side, or 600 pounds total.

  2. Does the Saatva sleep cool?

    The Saatva is designed to be breathable and to promote air flow. In our testing, we gave it an 8.5 out of 10.

Summary of Casper vs Saatva

Mattress Advisor Score Breakdown

Casper

Saatva

Shipping: 10

Trial Period: 9

Return Policy: 10            

Warranty: 9

Set-up Test: 8

Motion Transfer Test: 8

Edge Support Test: 9.5

Pressure Relief Test: 8.5

Spinal Alignment Test: 9.5

Responsiveness Test: 10

Cooling Evaluation: 7

Durability Evaluation: 8

Customer Service Score: 9          

Social Impact Score: 9

TOTAL SCORE: 9.1/10

Shipping: 9.5

Trial Period: 10

Return Policy: 8

Warranty: 10

Set-up Test: 10

Motion Transfer Test: 7.5

Edge Support Test: 8.5

Pressure Relief Test: 6.5

Spinal Alignment Test: 9.5

Responsiveness Test: 7.5

Cooling Evaluation: 8.5

Durability Evaluation: 10

Customer Service Score: 9

Social Impact Score: 7

TOTAL SCORE: 8.7/10

Casper Mattress

There’s much to admire about the Casper mattress, one of the top foam beds on the market. While it’s not as flashy as some of its competitors, the truth is that it’s a really good universal mattress, meaning it provides comfort and support for pretty much all kinds of sleepers. It’s as responsive as can be, offers great pressure relief, and sleeps cooler than your average memory foam mattress. It’s a product we can recommend with only the smallest caveats.

30% Off Bundles and 10% off Sitewide with code HOLIDAYFLASH


Check Price


Saatva Mattress

The Saatva luxury mattress is fancier and pricier than the Casper. For budget shoppers or those who prefer traditional memory foam, it’s probably a non-starter. But if you want to invest in hotel-quality comfort and long-lasting durability, Saatva is close to as good as it gets.

Get $200 off


Check Price


About the Author Josh Hurst

Josh Hurst lives and writes in Knoxville, TN. A recovering insomniac, he has a long-standing appreciation for the power of a good night's sleep.