Sealy Posturepedic Mattress Reviews

Sealy Posturepedic has been a leading mattress company for decades and its founding goes back to 1881 in – you guessed it - Sealy, Texas. It’s now part of Tempur-Sealy Intl., the largest mattress maker in the world. Sealy mattress prices span from the mid to upper-end.

Type of Construction

Sealy Posturepedic is a broad ranging mattress manufacturer, so they make all kinds of mattresses including innerspring, all-foam and hybrid (innerspring/foam combo) mattresses.

Overview of Sealy Posturepedic Mattress Collections

  Sealy Response Sealy Conform Sealy Hybrid
  Sealy Response inside Sealy Conform inside Sealy Hybrid inside
Construction Innerspring Memory Foam Innerspring / Foam
Collections
  1. Premium (best)
  2. Performance (better)
  3. Essential (good)
  1. Premium
  2. Performance
  3. Essential
  1. Premium
  2. Performance
  3. Essential
Starting Queen Price $499 $699 $1099

Top 5 Rated Sealy Posturepedic Mattresses

We rigorously test each and every Sealy mattress using our pressure mapping system, in addition to other performance tests, and these 5 Sealy mattresses are the best rated. We test petite, average and large body sizes in both the back and side sleeping positions and analyze the data. We also compare the beds to the other mattresses in our database.

You can click through to any of these beds and see the individual test results and expert video reviews.

Mattress Name Quick Overview Personal Recommendation  
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Cooper Mountain Plush Pillow Top photo
Sealy Posturepedic
Response Performance Cooper Mountain Plush Pillow Top
  • Collection: Performance
  • Comfort: Pillow top
  • Comfort Scale: 7
  • Coil Count: 911
  • Mattress Height: 14"
  • Price: $629
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
Personalized Recommendations - Learn More »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Cooper Mountain Cushion Firm photo
Sealy Posturepedic
Response Performance Cooper Mountain Cushion Firm
  • Collection: Performance
  • Comfort: Firm
  • Comfort Scale: 3
  • Coil Count: 911
  • Mattress Height: 12.5"
  • Price: $599
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
Personalized Recommendations - Learn More »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Sealy Posturepedic Response Premium Warrenville Cushion Firm photo
Sealy Posturepedic
Response Premium Warrenville Cushion Firm
  • Collection: Premium
  • Comfort: Firm
  • Comfort Scale: 3
  • Coil Count: 960
  • Mattress Height: 13"
  • Price: $839
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
Personalized Recommendations - Learn More »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Santa Paula Plush photo
Sealy Posturepedic
Response Performance Santa Paula Plush
  • Collection: Performance
  • Comfort: Plush
  • Comfort Scale: 5.5
  • Coil Count: 638
  • Mattress Height: 12"
  • Price: $489
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
Personalized Recommendations - Learn More »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Sealy Essentials Optimistic Plush photo
Sealy Conform
Essentials Optimistic Plush
  • Collection: Essentials
  • Comfort: Plush
  • Comfort Scale: 4
  • Coil Count: none
  • Mattress Height: 11.5"
  • Price: $829
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
Personalized Recommendations - Learn More »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed

The 5 Best Sealy Posturepedic Specs:

Product Name
Sealy Conform Essentials Optimistic Plush Mattress
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Cooper Mountain IV Cushion Firm Mattress
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Cooper Mountain IV Plush Pillow Top Mattress
Sealy Posturepedic Response Performance Santa Paula IV Plush Mattress
Sealy Posturepedic Response Premium Warrenville IV Cushion Firm Mattress
Queen Price

$829.00

$599.00

$629.00

$499.00

$839.00

Brand
Sealy
Sealy
Sealy
Sealy
Sealy
Mattress Comfort
Plush
Cushion Firm
Plush Pillow Top
Plush
Cushion Firm
Comfort Scale Number
4
3
7
5.5
3
Coil Count
No
911
911
638
960
Coil Gauge
No
15
15
14
15
Height
11.5
12.5
14
12
13
Comfort Padding Layers
Warranty
  • Non-prorated
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • Non-prorated
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • Non-prorated
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • Non-prorated
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • Non-prorated
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • Back Support System
    Quilt Top of Mattress
    Edge Support
    No
    Recommended For Side Sleepers Who Weigh
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • Recommended For Back Sleepers Who Weigh
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • Sealy Posturepedic Mattress Collection Comparisons & Key Features

    Sealy Response Line - traditional innerspring mattresses. There are 3 collections:

    Sealy Response Line
    1. Premium Collection - the top of the line have Response Pro HD Encased densely packed coils, Sealy Chill Gel Memory foam and an Allergen Protect cover.
    2. Performance Collection - mid range upgrade features include; Response Pro Encased Coil dual stage innerspring, DuraFlex coil border edge support, Sealy Cool Gel Foam and a Comfort Loft moisture wicking cover.
    3. Essential Collection - entry level collection features durable mainstays; Sealy’s Response Coil innerspring, Solid Edge HD edge support, Sealy CushionFoam and a knit cover.

    Sealy Conform Line – all memory foam mattresses are the all foam beds with 3 collections:

    Sealy Conform Line
    1. Premium Collection - similar to Performance, these top models add a Reinforced edge support system and a cool-to-the-touch, moisture wicking stretchable knit cover.
    2. Performance Collection - has the same Sealy Support Gel foam, adds a layer of Sealy Chill Gel Memory Foam, a DuraFlex edge support, and a moisture wicking stretchable knit cover.
    3. Essential Collection - entry level collection starts with Sealy Support Gel Foam, topped with Comfort Sense Gel Memory Foam, a Solid Edge HD edge support, and a stretchable knit cover.

    Sealy Hybrid Line combines foam on top of innersprings in 3 collections:

    Sealy Hybrid Line
    1. Premium Collection - the top end line builds on the Performance Collection features by adding a better cover that has cool-to-the-touch DuoChill and Allergen Protect.
    2. Performance Collection - features Sealy’s Response Pro Zoned Encased Coil innerspring, Immersion Advanced Memory Foam with Chill and a moisture wicking stretchable knit cover.
    3. Essential Collection - the entry level collection features Sealy’s Response Pro Encased Coil innerspring, Sealy Comfort Foam and a moisture wicking stretchable knit cover.
    PROS CONS
    • Wide selection of comforts and prices
    • Innerspring, foam and hybrid choices
    • Trusted brand
    • Several models test well are rate Recommend
    • Hard to compare across stores because the same models have different names

    Motion Base Options

    There are 3 adjustable base models for Sealy. Adjustable bases (also called Motion Bases) give you more options for a mattress; from sitting in bed and reading or working, or sleeping with your head or legs up, etc. Some even have features like massage. There are 3 models available with Sealy mattresses:

    Sealy Reflexion Up Adjustable Base Sealy Ease Adjustable Base Sealy Reflexion 4 Adjustable Base
    Sealy Reflexion 4 Adjustable Base

    This base model is only $50 less than the Sealy Ease Adjustable base, so it makes no sense to consider this one compared to what you get for the money.

    Not a good value.

    The Sealy Ease adjustable base features:

    • Independent head and foot control with a wireless remote
    • Head raises up to 60 degrees from flat, legs raise up to 50 degrees
    • Pre-programmed remote means no need to pair with base
    • Smart Sync™ pairing system for split mattress beds
    • Zero Standby Power System
    • Simple one-button preset ''return to flat'' position
    • Gravity release safety feature
    • UL962 certified
    • Lift capacity of 650lbs
    • Place directly on frame or floor with included 9-inch black metal legs
    • Fits inside bed furniture
    • Platform bed friendly

    See the bed

    The Sealy Reflextion 4 base features:

    • Wall-Glide design
    • Solid wood tapered furniture leg supports
    • Preset positions: reading and recline
    • Dual wave massage with 3 programmed settings
    • 3 programmed position settings
    • Wireless hand remote
    • Underbed night light
    • 15 minute auto timer

    See the bed

    Delivery Method

    Sealy Posturepedic mattresses are available in select stores or online, but not directly from Sealy. They are usually delivered by a retailer’s in-home delivery service. In-home delivery is typically offered for free, along with removal of an old existing mattress.

    More about the Sealy Posturepedic Brand

    Sealy is one of the oldest and largest mattress companies in America, and is best known for its Posturepedic mattresses and blue butterfly logo. A few years ago, it was purchased by Tempur-Pedic along with its sister brand, Stearns & Foster. Today the combined public company is called Tempur-Sealy and is the largest mattress company in the world.

    Sealy continues to make a wide range of mattresses, from entry level mattresses costing a few hundred dollars to mattresses priced up to a couple thousand. There are literally tens of millions of Sealy mattresses in use and it remains one of the most popular and widely used beds in America.

    Conclusion

    Sealy Posturepedic makes a wide variety of mattresses; all different types and prices. In general, they are a reputable brand. But with so many styles and models we cannot give a blanket recommendation to every mattress they make. We test each mattress they make and so we’ve highlighted some of the best ones above. There are many others that rate well and have positive consumer reviews.

    It’s important to zero in on specific mattresses and see how an individual model would fit with your needs. Things to consider are your body size, whether you are a back or side sleeper, whether you like firmer or softer mattresses and if you want premium features and materials. We gather all this information at an individual bed level so you can make a smart choice. When you find the mattress that meets your individual criteria, then Sealy is a safe, dependable choice.

    About The Author Joe Nashif

    A jack of all trades in the mattress industry, Joe is a merchandiser who’s seen the changes in the products and trends for many years. Active in Brazilian Jui Jitsu, along with related injuries, he enjoys resting at home with family, too.