beautyrest black bed

Beautyrest Black Mattress Review

Beautyrest Black is the top-of-the-line mattress collection from Simmons Beautyrest, one of the largest mattress manufacturers in America. In this review we’ll give you an overview of our testing results for these beds, as well as our recommendations on which beds are the best.

Beautyrest Mattress Collections

The Black mattress line is one of three collections from Beautyrest:

  1. Black (premium prices $1,799 to $4,799)
  2. Platinum (mid to upper range prices $1,079 to $2,049)
  3. Silver (lower to mid-range prices $399 to $1,453)

Type of Construction

Beautyrest Black mattresses are traditional innerspring mattresses with pocketed coils and different combinations of foam materials on top.

Beautyrest Black - An Overview

Beautyrest Black mattresses use a pocketed coil design that made Beautyrest famous. Pocketed coils help provide contouring support and also have the added benefit of reducing the transfer of motion when your bed partner moves. These mattresses also include premium foams like Micro Diamond Memory Foam that actually inject micro diamonds into the foam and help keep the bed cool. Since there are 13 models in this collection, they range broadly in features, prices, and soft to hard feels – more details are down the page:

Top 5 Beautyrest Black Mattresses

We’ve tested each and every Black mattress using our pressure mapping system, in addition to other performance tests and these 5 mattresses scored the best. We test petite, average and large body sizes in both the back and side sleeping positions, analyze the data, and then compare them to all the other mattresses. Click through to any of these beds and see the test results and expert video reviews.

Mattress Name Quick Overview Personal Recommendation  
Beautyrest Black Natasha Plush Pillow Top
Beautyrest Black
Natasha Plush Pillow Top
  • Collection: Black
  • Comfort: Soft
  • Comfort Scale: 8
  • Material: Innerspring
  • Mattress Height: 16"
  • Price: $2,799
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
personalized recommendations - learn more »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Beautyrest Black Sonya Luxury Firm Pillow Top photo
Beautyrest Black
Sonya Luxury Firm Pillow Top
  • Collection: Black
  • Comfort: Medium
  • Comfort Scale: 5
  • Material: Innerspring
  • Mattress Height: 18"
  • Price: $3,799
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
personalized recommendations - learn more »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Beautyrest Black Mariela Luxury Firm photo
Beautyrest Black
Mariela Luxury Firm
  • Collection: Black
  • Comfort: Firm
  • Comfort Scale: 3
  • Material: Innerspring
  • Mattress Height: 15"
  • Price: $2,599
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
personalized recommendations - learn more »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Beautyrest Black Tatiana Ultimate Plush Pillow Top photo
Beautyrest Black
Tatiana Ultimate Plush Pillow Top
  • Collection: Black
  • Comfort: Soft
  • Comfort Scale: 10
  • Material: Innerspring
  • Mattress Height: 18.5"
  • Price: $4.799
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
personalized recommendations - learn more »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed
Beautyrest Black Katarina Luxury Firm Pillow Top photo
Beautyrest Black
Katarina Luxury Firm Pillow Top
  • Collection: Black
  • Comfort: Medium
  • Comfort Scale: 4.5
  • Material: Innerspring
  • Mattress Height: 15"
  • Price: $2,399
  • Warranty: 10 Years
  • Guarantee: 120 Days
personalized recommendations - learn more »
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Back
Sleeper
Petite
Person
Average
Person
Large
Person
Side
Sleeper
view bed

Beautyrest Black Mattress Collection Comparison & Key Features

Product Name
Simmons Beautyrest Black Katarina Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress
Simmons Beautyrest Black Mariela Luxury Firm Mattress
Simmons Beautyrest Black Natasha Plush Pillow Top Mattress
Simmons Beautyrest Black Sonya Luxury Firm Pillow Top Mattress
Simmons Beautyrest Black Tatiana Ultimate Plush Pillow Top Mattress
Queen Price

$2,399.00

$2,599.00

$2,799.00

$3,799.00

$4,799.00

Brand
Simmons
Simmons
Simmons
Simmons
Simmons
Mattress Comfort
Luxury Firm Pillow Top
Luxury Firm
Plush Pillow Top
Luxury Firm Pillow Top
Ultimate Plush
Comfort Scale Number
4.5
3
8
5
10
Coil Count
850
850
850
1850
1850
Coil Gauge
13.5/17
13.5/17
14.7/17
13.5/17
14.7/17
Height
15
15
16
18
18.5
Comfort Padding Layers
Warranty
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • Non-prorated
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • Non-prorated
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • Non-prorated
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • Non-prorated
  • 10 year warranty against manufacturer's defects
  • No Flip, No Rotate
  • Non-prorated
  • Back Support System
  • 850 Series Beautyrest Variformed Advance Pocketed Coil
  • 850 Series Beautyrest Variformed Advance Pocketed Coil
  • 850 Series Beautyrest Variformed Advance Pocketed Coil
  • 850 Series Beautyrest Variformed Advance Pocketed Coil
  • 850 Series Beautyrest Variformed Advance Pocketed Coil
  • 1000 Beautyrest Micro Coils
  • Quilt Top of Mattress
  • SurfaceCoolPlus™ Fiber
  • 2 1/4'' Comfort Foam
  • SurfaceCoolPlus™ Fiber
  • 2 1/4'' Comfort Foam
  • SurfaceCoolPlus™ Fiber
  • 1 1/4'' Comfort Foam
  • SurfaceCoolPlus™ Fiber
  • 2 1/4'' Comfort Foam
  • SurfaceCoolPlus™ Fiber
  • 2 1/4'' Comfort Foam
  • Edge Support
  • 360 Degree 3'' Foam Encased Edge Support System
  • 360 Degree 3'' Foam Encased Edge Support System
  • 360 Degree 3'' Foam Encased Edge Support System
  • 360 Degree 3'' Foam Encased Edge Support System
  • 360 Degree 3'' Foam Encased Edge Support System
  • Recommended For Side Sleepers Who Weigh
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • Recommended For Back Sleepers Who Weigh
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • 210-273 lbs
  • 134-218 lbs
  • 111-135 lbs
  • PROS CONS
    • Available in various comforts to appeal to everybody
    • Premium quality foams and materials
    • Very good support and contouring
    • Minimal motion transfer
    • Durable triple strand pocketed coil
    • Trusted brand
    • Premium pricing above most mattresses
    • Very tall mattresses, whereas designers like lower profile mattresses

    More on Beautyrest Black Mattress Features

    beautyrest black cutaway 1 CONFORMING BACK SUPPORT

    The Advanced Pocketed Coil Technology provides individualized back support for everybody’s unique shape. The coils also provide enhanced conformability and pressure relief as well as motion separation from partner movements.

    The triple strand coils create greater durability compared to typical wrapped coils.

    2 COMFORT AND PRESSURE RELIEF

    Memory foam is infused with Micro Diamonds to conduct heat away from your body. It’s the actual properties of the diamond particles that move the heat away.

    It’s also engineered to work in concert with the Advanced Pocketed Coil system underneath.

    3 TEMPERATURE MANAGEMENT

    Beautyrest Black has what they call SurfaceCool Plus Fiber, vertically oriented fibers under the cover, that are designed to flow body heat away from the surface and help keep you cool while you sleep.

    Beautyrest Black Mattress Comparison Chart

    Here is a nice summary of the entire Black line of mattresses:

    beautyrest black comparison beautyrest black comparison

    Delivery Method

    Beautyrest Black mattresses are sold both in stores and online. They’re heavy mattresses and so they’re delivered by retailer delivery teams. In-home delivery is free, and so is removal of your old mattress.

    More about Simmons Beautyrest

    Simmons Mattress Company has been a leader in mattress manufacturing for over 100 years. Their Beautyrest flagship brand has been a household name for many decades. Many people remember the “bowling ball” commercial where a bowling ball was dropped on a mattress to highlight their pocketed coils (a glass of wine would sit undisturbed when the ball bounced on the other side of the bed.)

    In recent years Simmons merged with Serta into the Serta Simmons Bedding Company, making them one of the 2 largest mattress companies in the world (TempurSealy is the other.) Simmons now markets the Black, Platinum and Silver mattress collections.

    Being a large manufacturer, Simmons engineers and makes many of its own components in addition to manufacturing. With their longevity and size they have accumulated a lot of experience and knowledge making mattresses. Simmons makes millions of mattresses each year and they’ve maintained a positive reputation over the long run. While some review sites call out consumer complaints, those sites fail to provide the context that there are tens of millions of customers sleeping on Beautyrest mattresses. And all taken altogether Simmons Beautyrest has a highly positive customer reputation.

    Conclusion

    Beautyrest Black has a large collection of mattresses in a wide range of prices and comforts. They generally rate well and we’ve highlighted the top 5 beds based on our testing. These 5 beds did a great job distributing body weight minimizing pressure points that can disturb your sleep. They also did very well supporting the different body sizes and sleeping positions.

    The Natasha Plush Pillow Top mattress rated the best and is a ‘Recommend’ for every body size and sleeping position. It also has favorable customer reviews and is a popular model in the Black line so it’s a great choice if you like a super soft bed.

    These mattresses are expensive and cost more than average so they’re not for everybody’s budget. But they do come with extra features like the durable triple strand coils and diamond infused foams, as examples. These features add value, but if they’re worth it is up to you

    About The Author Joe Nashif

    A jack of all trades in the mattress industry, Joe is a merchandiser who’s seen the changes in the products and trends for many years. Active in Brazilian Jui Jitsu, along with related injuries, he enjoys resting at home with family, too.